Could Trump get hush money conviction overturned with SCOTUS immunity…

2024-07-03
Could Trump get hush money conviction overturned with SCOTUS immunity…

Trump's Uphill Battle: Immunity Ruling Unlikely to Overturn Hush Money Conviction

Former President Donald Trump faces an arduous challenge in his attempt to overturn his Manhattan hush money conviction, despite the Supreme Court's recent ruling granting presidents immunity for "official acts." Legal experts believe the high court's decision has little chance of impacting Trump's state-level conviction, as the alleged cover-up of payments to a porn star is unlikely to be considered an official presidential duty.

Uncovering the Truth: Trump's Bid to Overturn Conviction Faces Steep Odds

Challenging the Evidence

Trump's legal team is arguing that prosecutors in the Manhattan District Attorney's Office improperly allowed jurors to hear evidence from Trump's time in the White House, including key testimony from his former top communications aide, Hope Hicks. Hicks testified that Trump, in a 2018 conversation when he was president, felt "it was better to be dealing" with sex allegations from porn star Stormy Daniels at that time than before the 2016 election. The testimony was described as "devastating" evidence that the hush money payment to Daniels was part of an illegal "conspiracy" to hide her story from voters in 2016.Trump's lawyers claim that the jury was improperly allowed to hear this testimony and other evidence from the ex-president's stint in the White House, arguing that it unfairly influenced the jury. They assert that this "official-acts evidence should never have been put before the jury" and that, after further briefing on these issues, "it will be manifest that the trial result cannot stand."

The Immunity Question

In an ironic twist, experts suggest that Trump may have had a stronger argument on the immunity question if his ex-fixer, Michael Cohen, had been part of the administration during the alleged cover-up scheme. As Cohen was not a White House employee, it is "hard to argue that what Michael Cohen was up to was in anyway an 'official' act," according to attorney Steven Cohen.The Supreme Court's recent ruling on presidential immunity has dealt a blow to the federal election-interference case against Trump, but legal experts believe it is unlikely to overturn his state-level conviction in the Manhattan hush money case. They argue that covering up payments to a porn star is not part of the core constitutional duties of the presidency, and that the challenged evidence from Trump's time in the White House is likely to be considered "harmless" by appeals courts.

The Road Ahead

Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Juan Merchan has left open the possibility that he could side with Trump and vacate the jury's May 30 verdict, which found the ex-president guilty on 34 felony counts of falsifying business records. However, legal experts believe it is more likely that Merchan will rule that Trump's actions in covering up the Daniels hush money payment throughout 2017, including by signing checks to his Michael Cohen while sitting in the Oval Office, are not part of a president's official duties.The judge may then leave questions about whether prosecutors inappropriately used trial evidence from Trump's time in the White House for appeals courts to decide. While it is unlikely that the state appeals court will throw out the conviction based on the immunity issue, defense lawyer Robert Gottlieb cautioned that "in today's legal world that has been upside down, I would be a fool to say anything is impossible."Trump is currently scheduled to be sentenced on September 18, but the date may be subject to further delays as the court and prosecution aim to address the ex-president's claims. Despite the legal challenges, experts believe that the conviction is unlikely to be overturned, as the hush money payment and cover-up were outside the scope of Trump's official presidential duties.

Article "tagged" as:

Related Article

195 Cute Cat Names

195 Cute Cat Names

If you've welcomed a new cat into your home and they need a name, try giving them one of these cute names, including cute names for girl cats, boy cats, orange cats, gray cats, and more.
Luxating Patella in Cats

Luxating Patella in Cats

Luxating patella is an orthopedic condition that affects cats' knees. Learn the causes, treatment, and prevention.
Salivary Mucocele in Dogs

Salivary Mucocele in Dogs

A salivary mucocele, also called a sialocele, causes swelling near a dog's salivary glands and may cause a lump under the chin or on the neck near the jaw. Learn the causes, treatment, and prevention of salivary mucoceles in dogs.
Folliculitis in Dogs

Folliculitis in Dogs

Folliculitis is a common skin condition in dogs. Learn the causes, treatment, and prevention.
Is Baking Soda Bad for Cats?

Is Baking Soda Bad for Cats?

Baking soda has many common household uses and may help with cat odors, but how much is safe to use around cats?
Can Dogs Eat Parmesan Cheese?

Can Dogs Eat Parmesan Cheese?

It's no secret that dogs love cheese, but what kinds of cheese should you avoid? Is Parmesan cheese a good option to treat your pup to?
Can Dogs Eat Pistachios?

Can Dogs Eat Pistachios?

Dogs can eat pistachios, but only if they're plain and served in moderation. In other cases, pistachios can be harmful for dogs.
Can Dogs Eat Cheese?

Can Dogs Eat Cheese?

A popular training tool, cheese is OK for most dogs to enjoy on special occasions...but there are some exceptions.
Snowshoe Cat: Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

Snowshoe Cat: Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

The snowshoe cat, a mix of the American shorthair and Siamese, is a smart and affectionate pet that loves company. Learn about the snowshoe cat breed, including temperament, appearance, and care needs.
Bearded Collie: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Bearded Collie: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Learn about bearded collies, energetic and intelligent dogs known for their herding skills and bearded faces that earned the nickname "beardies."
How to Plant a Border Garden that Will Add Color to Your Landscape

How to Plant a Border Garden that Will Add Color to Your Landscape

Learn how to create a vibrant border garden that will compliment your landscape and provide visual appeal of completeness.
Are Petunias Perennials or Annuals? Plus Tips for Getting Tons of Flowers

Are Petunias Perennials or Annuals? Plus Tips for Getting Tons of Flowers

Are petunias perennials that come back each year? The answer is yes and no, depending on your climate. Find out how to grow petunias as annuals or perennials.
How to Plant and Grow Golden Bamboo

How to Plant and Grow Golden Bamboo

Learn how to grow golden bamboo, a perennial often used for outdoor privacy. Unfortunately, it can be invasive, so be careful where you plant it.
How to Plant and Grow Camellia

How to Plant and Grow Camellia

Learn to plant and grow camellia, the Southern belles of the plant world. These evergreen shrubs bear beautiful blooms during the colder months.
This Daylily-Filled Garden Plan Lets You Flaunt Your Favorites

This Daylily-Filled Garden Plan Lets You Flaunt Your Favorites

Combine daylily varieties of your choice with other reliable plants for tons of carefree color.
29 Flower Pot Ideas for Stunning Mixes of Blooms and Foliage

29 Flower Pot Ideas for Stunning Mixes of Blooms and Foliage

Use these flower pot ideas for beautiful combinations to brighten up your porch, patio, or other spots that need a boost of color.
Which Types of Garlic Are Best to Grow in Your Garden?

Which Types of Garlic Are Best to Grow in Your Garden?

Hardneck or softneck? Here’s what to know about different types of garlic and how to grow them.
When Is the Best Time to Mow Your Lawn?

When Is the Best Time to Mow Your Lawn?

Take the guesswork out of deciding when to mow your lawn with our easy-to-follow tips.
How to Start a Garden: 10 Easy Steps for Beginners

How to Start a Garden: 10 Easy Steps for Beginners

This step-by-step guide explains how to start a garden for beginners. It covers all the basics you need to know, including what to plant, prepping soil, and care tips.
How to Get Rid of Pokeweed in Your Yard

How to Get Rid of Pokeweed in Your Yard

Although this plant is native to parts of North America, pokeweed is still an aggressive, toxic plant you may not want around. Use these tips to safely eliminate pokeweed from your garden.